arXiv Science⌕ Search
Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2609.30200

High Rank and Multiplicity in Random and Perfect Profinite Groups

Carlo Pagano·Mark Shusterman
View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

We prove that almost sure topological finite generation holds for a general class of random models of profinite groups. We deduce that in the models introduced by Liu--Wood and Sawin--Wood, one has that finite presentation holds almost surely, with almost sure control of the deficiency in the presentation. In particular this settles questions raised in work of Liu--Wood and Sawin--Wood. Using the same underlying principle, we show that there exists a unique universal d-generated perfect profinite group: its finite quotients are precisely the finite d-generated perfect groups. This settles a conjecture of Nikolov. We show in addition that this group is projective and admits a profinite presentation with $d$ generators and $d$ relations, and with no fewer relations on $d$ generators. The main underlying theme is to bring in an insight from crown theory: groups with high rank are always witnessed by a crown with large multiplicity. This approach was discovered independently by ChatGPT5.5 pro and Aletheia, an internal agent at Google DeepMind.

Explore related subjects

math.GRmath.NT

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Carlo Pagano, Mark Shusterman. 2026-09-24. High Rank and Multiplicity in Random and Perfect Profinite Groups. https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.30200

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

The Haagerup property for groups and for tracial von Neumann algebras in terms of invariant and mixing states

The aim of the article is to provide two characterizations of the Haagerup property: one for locally compact, second countable groups, and the other one for finite von Neumann algebras. Both are expressed in terms of approximations of some non-ergodic invariant states by mixing ones for actions on unital $C^*$-algebras on the one hand, and for pairs of tracial von Neumann algebras by mixing binormal states on the other hand.

math.GR↗
arXiv2026

The McCullough-Miller complex for right angled Artin groups

McCullough and Miller constructed a contractible complex on which the pure symmetric automorphism group of a free group acts with free abelian stabilizers. This complex has been used for computations such as the cohomological dimension of these groups, their cohomology rings, and results about $\ell^2$-Betti numbers or BNRS-invariants. We generalize this construction to pure symmetric automorphism groups of arbitrary RAAGs and exhibit applications of this generalization.

math.GR↗
arXiv2026

The quantitative non-unique-product landscape at the global minimum: the Nielsen-Soelberg groups

Nielsen and Soelberg proved that a finite subset $A$ of a torsion-free group with $A\cdot A$ having no unique product satisfies $|A|\ge 8$, and exhibited two groups, here $G_1$ and $G_2$, attaining the bound. Nothing quantitative was known about these extremal configurations. We construct exact, independently verified models of both groups and compute the first quantitative invariants at the global minimum. In $G_1$ no $8$-element symmetric witness lies in the radius-$6$ ball ($933$ elements, certified infeasible), while the Nielsen-Soelberg witness lies in the radius-$7$ ball: the global minimum is spread out. In $G_2$, with its natural eight-generator metric, the witness and its inverse are the only two non-UP $8$-sets in the radius-$1$ ball, and the unique-product staircase takes the value $0$ at $n=8$ but $1$ at $n=9$ -- the first known minimizer whose square has exactly one uniquely represented element, so the simultaneous failure of t.u.p. and u.p. seen in the Promislow group is not universal. No $(7,9)$ two-sided witness exists in the searched balls, so the Nielsen-Soelberg profile bound may not be sharp. Finally we treat the universal group $G_3$. Its structure is known -- Soelberg's thesis identifies an index-$8$ Heisenberg subgroup of step $8$ and proves torsion-freeness, and Gardam, studying the same group as an amalgam of Klein bottle groups, shows it to be virtually nilpotent but not virtually abelian -- and what we add is a model in search coordinates in which balls can be enumerated. In it we reproduce the Nielsen-Soelberg two-sided pair and exhibit a symmetric $15$-element witness whose trivial-coset singleton generates the centre of that Heisenberg subgroup. It is rigid and rare: within $B(5)$ the size $15$ is exactly minimal, the coset profile is forced, and exactly four such witnesses exist in $B(4)$, one orbit. Hence $m_1(G_3)\in[8,15]$ against $m_2(G_3)=16$.

math.GR↗