Copula Geometry and Second-Order Calibration of Heavily Right Aggregation

Abstract

Heavy-tailed $p$-value combination tests are attractive under unknown dependence because their null tails can be first-order robust even when the exact dependent null distribution is unavailable. That robustness does not resolve calibration: $\Pr\{T>q(α)\}=α+o(α)$ neither quantifies the remaining size error nor determines its sign. We develop a second-order calibration theory for positive Half-Cauchy and reciprocal, or harmonic-mean, aggregation. After exact marginal standardization, extremal dependence is represented by an index-one exponent measure on the coordinate-face lattice. Its support separates axial, full-interior, proper-face, and mixed geometries. A Möbius decomposition shows how the noncompact weighted half-space probes every face, while quantitative face limits determine whether the correction is integrable, critically amplified, or nonintegrable. With common-factor inversion and a tail-to-calibration map, this yields machinery applicable beyond individual parametric copula families. The results include an integrable hidden-face transfer theorem, a sharp fixed-dimensional local-corner theorem with explicit higher-face control, a common-heavy-factor theorem, and size and critical-value expansions relative to independence. Gaussian, standard multivariate-$t$, positive Clayton, and max-linear pair-shock models exhibit distinct power, logarithmic, radial--angular, and proper-face mechanisms; the Gaussian weighted-half-space transfer is conditional on explicit face-boundary hypotheses. Thus dependence geometry determines the rate, coefficient, and direction of the calibration error left unresolved by first-order validity. Asymptotics use $t\to\infty$, equivalently vanishing significance levels.