Rank-two Nahm sums, modularity obstructions, and the McKay--Thompson series $T_{31A}$

Abstract

We conjecture a positive four-shift identity for rank-two Nahm sums with denominator steps $(1,31)$, giving a mixed-base realization of the Monster McKay--Thompson series $T_{31A}$ through the classical Rogers--Ramanujan function $U(1,31)$. A theta dissection directly derives the modular target. For the underlying quadratic exponent $3r^2+31rs+93s^2$, we prove nonmodularity of every individual sum with rational linear terms and normalization, together with an exclusion from finite Fricke systems with meromorphic finite-width expansions at infinity. Exact agreement through $q^{2000}$ and six vanishing radial corrections support the proposed combination; a five-term dilogarithm certificate and an exact amplitude calculation prove its leading asymptotic behavior. We further propose a three-component Fricke law for a dual combination, with an explicit icosahedral matrix involving fifth-root constants, and a quadratic identity linking its components to $T_{31A}$. The dual translation law and matrix algebra are proved; its Fricke transformation and moonshine identity remain conjectural, supported respectively by numerical evaluations and exact finite coefficient checks.