arXiv Science⌕ Search
Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2609.27561

Characterizing the Carnot cycle at absolute zero: a reply to "Comment on `Proof of the Nernst theorem' "

José-María Martín-Olalla
View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

This reply addresses a recent comment concerning the proof of the Nernst theorem. I clarify how a Carnot engine can consistently operate at $T=0$ through a continuous deformation of a cycle operating at $T>0$. By examining the limit where heat exchange with the cold reservoir vanishes, I show that the Nernst theorem ensures that the concept of temperature remains physically consistent at the absolute zero limit.

Explore related subjects

physics.class-ph

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

José-María Martín-Olalla. 2026-09-23. Characterizing the Carnot cycle at absolute zero: a reply to "Comment on `Proof of the Nernst theorem' ". https://doi.org/10.1140/epjp%2Fs13360-026-08111-8

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

Repeated Binary Direct Collinear Impacts Under Incremental Contact Laws With Permanent Indentation: A Hybrid Systems Formulation

Incremental contact laws specify the normal contact force through a differential equation carrying an internal state, driven by the indentation and its rate. In some, the force is extinguished at a nonzero indentation, whether by plastic deformation or by an elastic aftereffect, so that a residual deformation remains at the separation. Such laws sit uneasily within rigid body dynamics, which admits no deformation. The tension is tolerable when the indentation is small relative to the bodies, so that it may be carried constitutively rather than geometrically. Even then, the contact law alone does not determine the interaction of the bodies. Because force and indentation no longer vanish together, conditions for the commencement and termination of contact must be supplied separately. So must the fate of the deformation and internal state at separation, neither of which the equations of motion contain. This article formulates the repeated direct collinear impact of two convex bodies under external forces as a hybrid dynamical system. The contact interface is modeled as a massless element carrying the contact law and its state, coupled to the bodies through relative velocity and an interaction force dictated by the contact state. Consequently, all switching and resets are confined to the interface, leaving the geometry and the equations of motion of the bodies unaltered. The principal analytical properties of the resulting formulations are established, among them passivity and completeness; the branching of solutions at the onset and termination of contact is also examined. The framework is demonstrated through numerical simulations.

physics.class-ph↗
arXiv2026

Unifying pendulum-like dynamical regimes via complex time

We present an alternative derivation of exact solutions for pendulum-like systems across all dynamical regimes using a standard technique in undergraduate mathematical physics course: the Cauchy residue theorem, entirely independent from the traditional Jacobi elliptic framework. The solutions are exact in both the time and frequency domains, providing continuous trajectories and precise frequency decompositions. Pendulum-like dynamics is a foundational model across many areas of physics, underlying systems ranging from classical nonlinear oscillators to superconducting qubits and cold-atom tunneling platforms. While its time-domain solutions are well-known in terms of Jacobi elliptic functions, its obscured frequency-domain solutions have led a large body of theoretical and experimental work to develop and apply approximate methods when studying its spectral behavior. We discover that all regimes arise from a single spectral kernel, with parity selection distinguishing the periodic motions and the separatrix representing their discrete-to-continuum limit. Regime changes thus correspond to symmetry-driven reorganizations in frequency space rather than changes in the underlying spectral structure, with the stopping trajectory representing the continuum limit. By completely bypassing the traditional Jacobi elliptic functions, and relying on the symmetrical structure of the complex time plane, the derivation shows that the symmetrical spectral structure is not merely algebraic artifacts of elliptic integrals, but fundamentally connected to the dynamical symmetries of the system. The derivation presented here not only serves as a powerful pedagogical exercise for this long-standing physics problem, but also reveals a highly symmetrical spectral organization in nonlinear dynamics.

physics.class-ph↗
arXiv2026

Spectral taxonomy for quartic systems: fundamental clock, parity, and continuum

A symmetric quartic potential is a physics model with expansive applications, ranging from broadband energy harvesters, quantum tunneling in molecules and the early universe, to torque-free spacecraft rotation. Its rich dynamics have been traditionally classified into regimes and expressed as disjointed time-domain solutions. Here we build a taxonomy for this broad class of motions and discover that their regimes exhibit a symmetrical spectral structure: they share a fundamental clock, obey parity selection, and dissolve into the separatrix through a discrete-to-continuum transition. Applied to the famous Dzhanibekov effect where a rotating body periodically undergoes rapid 180-degree flips in its attitude, the taxonomy reveals its spectral anatomy. The three principal-axis rotations share a common clock while occupying distinct parity channels, with stable-axis branches exchanging DC bias across the separatrix. We discuss a case study where the three spectral pillars: clock, parity, and continuum, survive the Wick rotation from real-time into imaginary-time kinematics.

physics.class-ph↗