The universe as a superconductor: How to search for a photon mass

Abstract

We revisit the bounds on the photon mass when it arises from an Abelian Higgs mechanism rather than a Proca term. Because the higgs is necessarily millicharged and light, the phase of the theory (Meissner, vortex, or symmetry-restored) depends on the ambient magnetic field, so the photon mass an experiment measures depends on the environment it is performed in. We classify existing experiments by the phases in which they apply, in analogy with Type I and Type II superconductors. For Type I photon masses, magnetic fields in galaxies and the intergalactic medium can restore the symmetry everywhere, allowing a vacuum photon mass as large as $0.3 \,{\rm MeV}$. Regions of photon mass as large as $10^{-5}\, {\rm eV}$ could be present in the Universe, and measurement of frequency dependent optical depth can potentially reveal these regions. For Type II photon masses, we show that the strongest constraints mainly arise from the requirement that the galactic dynamo generates the observed magnetic fields, which we derive by generalizing magnetohydrodynamics to a nonzero photon mass. Since the terrestrial magnetic field restores the symmetry in much of the remaining parameter space, laboratory searches performed inside large magnetically shielded volumes, or in space, could probe photon masses invisible to any experiment on Earth. Measurements of distant light sources, in particular, fast radio bursts, also offer unique sensitivity to parameters invisible to lab experiments.