Stationary common-neighborhood properties and partition hypotheses

Abstract

We use stationary common-neighborhood properties to study highly connected Ramsey relations and partition hypotheses. For weakly compact $κ$, $\operatorname{Coll}(ω_1,{<}κ)$ forces $ω_2\to_{\mathrm{hc},<5}(ω_2)^2_ω$ and $\operatorname{PH}_1(ω_2)$. If $κ$ is $T^{κ^+}_{ω_1}$-Ramsey, the same collapse forces that every countable coloring of $[ω_2]^2$ has a stationary set $X\subseteqω_2$ and a color $i$ such that every finite subset of $X$ has stationarily many color-$i$ common neighbors in $X$. From one weakly compact cardinal, we obtain a model of the ${<}5$-edge relation at $ω_3$ and $\operatorname{PH}_1(ω_3)$, in which $\check H^2(ω_3,A_d)\ne0$ for every nontrivial abelian group $A$. This separates $\operatorname{PH}_1(ω_3)$ from $\operatorname{PH}_2(ω_3)$, with the exact consistency strength of one weakly compact cardinal. We also show that $\operatorname{PH}_1(ω_2\timesω_5)$ is equiconsistent with two weakly compact cardinals.