arXiv Science⌕ Search
Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2609.22404

Behavior Trees for Robotic Systems: An Empirical Study on Practices and Experiences

Razan Ghzouli·Jennifer Horkoff·Daniel Strüber·Rebekka Wohlrab
View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Over the last decade, behavior trees (BT) have become one of the dominant behavior models for coordinating missions of robotic systems. Yet empirical evidence on BT adoption in real-world contexts remains limited, especially regarding practitioners experiences and practices. Without practitioner-grounded evidence from both academic and industrial settings, the research community risks developing guidelines and tools that are plausible in principle but only partly aligned with real challenges. This scarcity of evidence leads to ad-hoc practices, impeding software reuse, maintenance, and evolution. This paper reports a mixed-methods study combining a technical action research investigation at an automotive company with a survey of 34 robotics practitioners. Our results indicate that BTs improve team communication and the understandability of robotic decision-making logic, reflecting BTs practical value beyond mission coordination. At the same time, practitioners face multiple non-trivial design and integration decisions, complicated by the lack of adequate guidelines and tool support. These decisions span architectural and language choices when implementing BTs and integrating them within ROS, for which we report observed patterns. Additionally, practitioners faced multi-factor granularity decisions and mixed experiences with current libraries. For the most used BT libraries, they reported implementation challenges and documentation gaps. Regarding planning algorithms, practitioners find deciding optimal BT node ordering challenging. Views on scalability remained inconclusive, and limitations in current libraries and practices hinder broader adoption. We conclude with cross-cutting observations and implications for both practitioners adopting BTs in robotic systems and researchers aiming to advance empirical understanding of BT adoption.

Explore related subjects

cs.ROcs.SE

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Razan Ghzouli, Jennifer Horkoff, Daniel Strüber, Rebekka Wohlrab. 2026-09-18. Behavior Trees for Robotic Systems: An Empirical Study on Practices and Experiences. https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.22404

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

A Scalable Multi-Robot Framework for Decentralized and Asynchronous Perception-Action-Communication Loops

We develop a decentralized Perception-Action-Communication (PAC) system for multi-robot teams that enables them to collaborate in large scale, outdoor environments. Our system natively supports deployments at any scale by leveraging a graph neural network (GNN) to diffuse information hop-by-hop across the fleet's network. This achieves global collaboration from individual robots limited to local sensing and communication. Fully asynchronous, the core modules of PAC: perception, inter-robot communication, message aggregation and action are clocked at different frequencies with information flowing between them through buffers. We implement the PAC system as a series of highly extensible ROS2 nodes to serve as the foundational infrastructure for deployable swarm systems. PAC is validated in the real world with outdoor experiments with up to N=20 quadrotor robots and in simulations based on real-world data with up to N=100. These validations show that our system upholds crucial properties for field-deployable robot collectives: scalability, resiliency and repeatability.

cs.RO↗
arXiv2026

DexWrist: A Robotic Wrist for Constrained and Dynamic Manipulation

Development of dexterous manipulation hardware has primarily focused on hands and grippers. However, these end-effectors are often paired with bulky and highly stiff wrists that limit performance in human environments. More recent designs have adopted backdrivable actuation, but are still difficult to model and control due to coupled kinematics or high mechanical inertia from heavy links. We present DexWrist, a compact robotic wrist combining quasi-direct-drive actuation with a decoupled parallel kinematic mechanism to advance manipulation in highly constrained environments and enable dynamic, contact-rich tasks. It delivers 3.75$\pm$0.05 Nm rated torque, 0.33$\pm$0.06 Nm backdrive torque, 10.15$\pm$1.34 Hz torque bandwidth, $\pm 40^\circ$ ROM in both DOFs, and a diagonal velocity-constraint Jacobian (one-to-one motor-to-DOF mapping) in a 0.97 kg package. In practice, these properties increase workspace in clutter and stabilize contact without finely tuned admittance control. We evaluate DexWrist as a drop-in upgrade in simulation and on three robot arms across constrained and contact-rich tasks. In learned policy evaluations on the AgileX PiPER and UR3e, DexWrist achieved 50-76% relative improvements in success rate and reduced autonomous task completion times by 3-5x; on a torque-controlled Franka FR3, where a strong joint-impedance baseline already succeeds, it still completed the task 1.4x faster. Project page and videos: https://martinpeticco.com/dexwrist

cs.RO↗
arXiv2026

Imagine2Act: Leveraging Object-Action Motion Consistency from Imagined Goals for Robotic Manipulation

Relational object rearrangement (ROR) tasks (e.g., insert flower to vase) require a robot to manipulate objects with precise semantic and geometric reasoning. Existing approaches either rely on pre-collected demonstrations that struggle to capture complex geometric constraints or generate goal-state observations to capture semantic and geometric knowledge, but fail to explicitly couple object transformation with action prediction, resulting in errors due to generative noise. To address these limitations, we propose Imagine2Act, a 3D imitation-learning framework that incorporates semantic and geometric constraints of objects into policy learning to tackle high-precision manipulation tasks. We first generate imagined goal images conditioned on language instructions and reconstruct corresponding 3D point clouds to provide robust semantic and geometric priors. These imagined goal point clouds serve as additional inputs to the policy model, while an object-action consistency strategy with soft pose supervision explicitly aligns predicted end-effector motion with generated object transformation. This design enables Imagine2Act to reason about semantic and geometric relationships between objects and predict accurate actions across diverse tasks. Experiments in both simulation and the real world demonstrate that Imagine2Act outperforms previous state-of-the-art policies. More visualizations can be found at https://sites.google.com/view/imagine2act.

cs.RO↗