A Reachable-State Operator Formulation of Deferred Acceptance: Progress Invariants and Structural Diagnostics

Abstract

We give a reachable-state operator formulation of one-to-one deferred acceptance with strict, possibly incomplete preference lists. A local update operator is defined for each active proposer, while a scheduler selects which local update is applied. On the states reachable from the canonical empty initial state, three invariants are immediate: the set of proposed edges grows strictly, every proposer visits each acceptable receiver at most once, and every receiver holds its most-preferred proposal received so far. These invariants yield termination after at most |E| proposals and stability of every terminal reachable state. The classical rejection lemma then gives proposer optimality and schedule independence. We separate these trajectory statements from two logically different results: the distributive-lattice structure of the full stable-matching set and one-sided strategy-proofness. A diagnostic table records which proof obligation is lost when a model changes the bipartition, ordinal comparisons, proposal irreversibility, or receiver choice rule. The paper makes no new complexity claim; its purpose is a precise operator-level account of the classical proof architecture and of the limits of that architecture.