An Operative Viability Boundary for Relaxed Single-Particle Penrose Extraction in Kerr-Vaidya Spacetimes

Abstract

We present a corrected numerical investigation of the Penrose process in the Kerr-Vaidya metric for a rotating black hole losing mass at constant rate. We fix two errors from an earlier version: an incorrect metric component g_r phi (verified by transformation from Boyer-Lindquist coordinates) and the omission of the Wald/Christodoulou area theorem in the split optimization. Using the standard single-particle treatment (energy and angular momentum conserved at the split, but not the escaping fragment's radial momentum), we compute optimal trajectories and the bounded energy gain Delta E = E3 - E1 versus spin a/M and mass-loss rate alpha. For static Kerr holes, Delta E rises with spin from about 0.106 M at a/M = 0.8 to 0.245 M at a/M = 0.99. In the dynamic case, holding a fixed while m(v) decreases causes the effective spin a/m(v) to drift strongly toward extremality (from 0.81 to 0.9999), a geometric effect that makes static-dynamic comparisons at equal nominal a/M misleading. We map the critical mass-loss rate alpha_crit(a) above which no viable extraction is found (using m >= 0), obtaining alpha_crit(0.90) ~ 0.036, alpha_crit(0.95) ~ 0.019 and alpha_crit(0.99) ~ 0.0038, decreasing with spin. A check with full four-momentum conservation recovers the Bardeen-Press-Teukolsky bound near the horizon, but escaping solutions are rare away from it; thus our main results refer to the relaxed single-particle formulation common in the literature.