Hu-Sawicki $f(R)$ Gravity in a Non-Flat Universe: Constraints from DESI-DR2, BBN, and Type Ia Supernovae

Abstract

Late-time cosmic acceleration is conventionally ascribed to a cosmological constant, though $Λ$CDM continues to face several theoretical difficulties that keep alternative gravity models under active consideration. This work examines the Hu-Sawicki $f(R)$ model in a spatially non-flat background, with the modified-gravity parameter $b$ and the curvature density $Ω_k$ both treated as free parameters, constrained using DESI-DR2 BAO, BBN, and four Type Ia supernova compilations -- PantheonPlus, PantheonPlus+SH0ES, Union3, and DESY5yr. Across all four combinations, $H_0$ and $Ω_m$ stay close to their $Λ$CDM values, with a noticeable shift in $H_0$ appearing only for the SH0ES-calibrated dataset. The parameter $b$ departs from zero at better than $2σ$ in three of the four fits, most prominently for DESY5yr, whereas the SH0ES-calibrated combination alone prefers $b<0$. A strong positive correlation among $b$, $H_0$, and $Ω_k$ underlies this shift, suggesting that curvature signatures obtained under $Λ$CDM can be reabsorbed into the modified-gravity sector once this additional freedom is allowed. Statistical model comparison via AIC and BIC gives a mixed picture: AIC leans toward the Hu-Sawicki model in three of the four combinations, while BIC's heavier penalty on the extra parameter favors $Λ$CDM in most cases, and only DESY5yr is preferred under both criteria. These findings show that the Hu-Sawicki $f(R)$ scenario with unconstrained curvature is nonetheless a statistically feasible, if not obviously preferred, alternative to $Λ$CDM, and that curvature restrictions generated inside $Λ$CDM cannot be viewed as independent of the underlying gravity model.