Observational constraints on net radiative forcing confirm aviation contrail warming

Abstract

Contrail cirrus represents a critical component of aviation's non-CO2 climate impact, but its net radiative forcing, the balance between longwave warming and shortwave cooling, remains poorly constrained by direct observations. As a result, current assessments rely almost exclusively on microphysical models such as CoCiP and global climate simulations. Existing empirical estimates are largely restricted to young, linear tracks, because satellite detection masks have a poor recall of contrails once they spread and merge with natural cirrus, leaving a structural gap in our understanding of long-lived, non-linear contrail cirrus. To address this we use a causal framework that isolates the net radiative contrail effect of flight traffic over the Americas. Building on recent progress that quantified the longwave warming contrail effect using advected flight paths as a proxy for contrails, we expand this continuous treatment approach to capture the highly skewed shortwave cooling impact, delivering a 12-hour lifespan net observational radiative forcing. Our analysis reveals a statistically significant net warming energy forcing of 33.7 (95% CI: 20.8, 47.8) GJ per km flown from April 2019 to April 2020, providing a large-scale empirical quantification of long contrail lifespan impact of the same order as, though somewhat larger than, previous bottom-up simulation estimates. This observational benchmark offers an independent line of evidence on the sign and magnitude of the climate impact of contrails.