Ramsey Obstructions to Disambiguation

Abstract

A partial matrix has entries in $\{0,1,\star\}$, and a disambiguation replaces each $\star$ by $0$ or $1$. We construct partial matrices whose fully specified submatrices satisfy strong restrictions, yet every disambiguation contains every binary matrix of a prescribed size. Our first result answers a question of Alon, Hanneke, Holzman and Moran on the disambiguation of linear classifiers with margin. For $0<\varepsilon<π/2$, let $M_\varepsilon^d$ be the partial matrix indexed by points of the unit sphere $\mathbb S^d$, with entry $0$ for pairs at spherical distance at most $\varepsilon$, $1$ for pairs at distance at least $π-\varepsilon$, and $\star$ otherwise. Although these matrices have VC-dimension bounded independently of $d$, we prove that every disambiguation contains every binary $k\times k$ matrix once $d$ is sufficiently large. This also yields a partial concept class of Littlestone dimension $1$ with no disambiguation of finite VC-dimension. We also construct, for every $k$, a finite partial matrix whose fully specified $2\times2$ submatrices are all constant, while every disambiguation contains every binary $k\times k$ matrix. A symmetric analogue holds for partial graphs: for every $k$, there exists a partial graph of VC-dimension at most $1$ whose fully specified induced subgraphs are all cliques or stable sets, yet every disambiguation contains every $k$-vertex graph as an induced subgraph. A disambiguation can be viewed as a $2$-coloring of the unspecified entries, making Ramsey theory a natural framework for forcing prescribed patterns. Our proofs draw on two recent Ramsey theorems: the geometric argument uses Pálvölgyi's Dense Block theorem, while the combinatorial constructions rely on the girth Ramsey theorem of Reiher and Rödl, a suitable strengthening of the induced Ramsey theorem.