Variance of random greedy independent sets in triangle-free graphs

Abstract

Inspect the vertices of a finite simple graph in uniformly random order, accepting each vertex if none of its neighbors has previously been accepted. Let $X_G$ be the number of accepted vertices. For every triangle-free graph with $n\ge2$ vertices and $e$ edges, we prove $\operatorname{Var}(X_G)\le e((n-2)/n)^2$, with equality precisely for edgeless graphs and connected stars. In particular, among trees of a given order, the star uniquely maximizes the variance, with value $(n-1)(n-2)^2/n^2$. Known expected vertex-deletion stability already yields the elementary baseline $\operatorname{Var}(X_G)\le e$. We obtain the sharp finite-order refinement by combining a stronger centered first-choice estimate with a triangle-free edge-count identity in the law of total variance.