Breakdown of Multipole Expansion in Emergent Electromagnetism

Abstract

We find a striking departure from simple electrostatics in a family of two-dimensional lattice models whose effective description takes the form of an emergent electromagnetism: a high-order multipolar charge configuration can induce an electric field characteristic of a \textit{lower-}order multipole. Studying the archetypical hardcore dimer and U(1) spin-1/2 link models, we trace this to a breakdown of the superposition principle: for dense charge configurations, there can be a nonlinear suppression, or even enhancement, of the far field compared to the linear expectation. Our work establishes that microscopic lattice-scale constraints in models for emergent electromagnetism can change the far-field behaviour to differ from often utilized long-wavelength descriptions in standard effective continuum models.