Batched Pandora's Box

Abstract

Motivated by numerous parallelizable stochastic search problems, most notable and timely among them being LLM inference-time scaling, we propose and study batched versions of the Pandora's Box problem of Weitzman. In particular, boxes are opened in capacity-constrained batches, each batch has a setup cost, and all rewards in a batch are revealed together. We consider two different variants, motivated by different application environments: one where boxes are reusable (i.e., can provide multiple i.i.d.~samples) and another where they are not. For both variants we rule out most ``simple'' natural heuristics, and also formally prove NP-hardness of approximation in the traditional sense. We then relax the problem to allow bi-criteria approximations, with respect to both rewards and setup costs, where we exhibit constant approximation algorithms for both the reusable and non-reusable settings. This is obtained through a linear-programming relaxation of Pandora's Box problem, followed by randomized or Pipage rounding.