Mutually orthogonal anti-Latin squares

Abstract

Anti-Latin squares were introduced in connection with non-linear secure network coding, and the extremal problem for large mutually orthogonal families is motivated by that setting. We study the maximum size $N_A(d)$ of a family of mutually orthogonal anti-Latin squares of order $d$. We prove that $N_L(d)+1\le N_A(d)\le N_L(d)+2$ for every $d\ge 3$, where $N_L(d)$ denotes the classical maximum size of a family of mutually orthogonal Latin squares of order $d$, and we show that in fact $N_A(3)=N_L(3)+1$ whereas $N_A(d)=N_L(d)+2$ for every $d\ge 4$. The upper bound is obtained by passing through balanced matrices, while the lower bound is given by a deterministic permutation argument. For all $d\ge 8$, and also for the exceptional order $d=6$, the upper bound is shown to be attainable by a general probabilistic construction. On the structural side, we show that a saturated family of size $d+1$ induces an affine plane of order $d$, and that the saturated case is characterized by the existence of an anti-coordinate grid decomposition; after transporting this condition to the fixed cell set $[d]^2$, it becomes a direction-completeness condition on the corresponding row-blocks and column-blocks. The remaining small orders are treated separately: $d=3$ is handled by direct analysis and classification of orthogonal triples, $d=4$ by an explicit saturated construction and an analysis of its finite-geometric structure, and $d=5$ and $d=7$ by explicit saturated examples arising from the random-grid framework. Thus $N_A(d)$ is determined in terms of $N_L(d)$ for every $d\ge3$, and its numerical value is obtained explicitly for every $3\le d\le9$.