arXiv Science⌕ Search
Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2608.28617

Can AI-Assisted Inquiry Enhance Students' Decision-Making Skills in Socio-Scientific Issues? A Three-Group Experimental Study on Climate Change

Dimitrios Gousopoulos
View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Climate change is a socio-scientific issue: it rests on science but cannot be settled by science, because any serious response forces people to weigh costs, values, and competing interests under uncertainty. Helping students make such decisions well is a central aim of science education, and the arrival of generative artificial intelligence raises a sharp question: does a conversational AI partner deepen students' reasoning, or simply do the thinking for them? This study tested whether AI-assisted inquiry improves secondary students' decision-making about climate change. Using a pretest-posttest design with three groups (AI-assisted inquiry, inquiry without AI, and traditional instruction; 270 students, 90 per group), reasoning was assessed across seven decision-making steps, from defining the problem to monitoring with adaptive management, using a four-level analytic rubric scored through content analysis with high inter-coder agreement. All three groups began at comparable, mostly low levels and all improved, but the gains differed sharply. The AI-assisted group improved most, ahead of inquiry-only and of traditional instruction. Between-group effect sizes on gains were large for AI-assisted versus traditional instruction and moderate-to-large for AI-assisted versus inquiry-only, with the clearest advantages on stakeholder engagement, alternatives, implementation, and monitoring. Within the AI group, the number of times students checked the AI's claims against the sources predicted their gains, and no student was flagged for over-reliance. The findings suggest that AI helps most when it is designed to question rather than to answer, and that the inquiry it is embedded in carries much of the benefit.

Explore related subjects

cs.CYphysics.soc-ph

Keep this discovery

BibTeXRIS

Dimitrios Gousopoulos. 2026-07-26. Can AI-Assisted Inquiry Enhance Students' Decision-Making Skills in Socio-Scientific Issues? A Three-Group Experimental Study on Climate Change. https://doi.org/10.62225/2583049x.2026.6.3.6516

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

Discover connections

cs.CY subjectphysics.soc-ph subject

Connections use source metadata and explicit phrase matches, not verified experimental comparisons.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

Behavioral calibration of mobile-phone GPS data for population-representative analyses

Mobile phone mobility data have transformed the study of human behavior, but demographic and behavioral biases can compromise their representativeness and distort population-level inference. Existing calibration approaches primarily address demographic and geographic representativeness, leaving behavioral discrepancies largely uncorrected. Here we introduce the Behavioral Population (BePop) framework, which jointly calibrates mobility data to representative demographic and behavioral distributions using census data and time-use surveys. BePop embeds mobility sequences into behavioral profiles and estimates person-level weights that align both population composition and daily activity patterns. Across three U.S. metropolitan areas, the framework consistently improves agreement between GPS-derived mobility and representative behavioral distributions, including time allocation, activity transitions, and mobility motifs. Calibration also substantially alters downstream mobility indicators, demonstrating that behavioral biases can propagate into commonly used mobility measures. Our results establish behavioral representativeness as a critical complement to demographic calibration and provide a general framework for population-representative mobility inference.

physics.soc-ph↗
arXiv2026

Toward a social psychology of AI: language-model agents reproduce human-like minimal-group bias

Language-model agents now interact in groups, but evaluations that probe memorised stereotype content or use models to simulate people leave this social behaviour unmeasured. We adapt the minimal-group paradigm---social psychology's classic test of intergroup bias---into a controlled probe: an agent distributes points among anonymous peers bearing only an arbitrary group label. Across four reasoning models, mere categorisation into meaningless groups elicited in-group favouritism that vanished under a group-blind control and was concentrated in the numerical minority: minority deciders over-allocated to their own group relative to their numbers, majority deciders allocated close to proportionally, and the asymmetry closed at equal group sizes. Disabling reasoning in one model did not remove the disposition---if anything it grew---but nearly erased the minority-majority asymmetry, implicating deliberation in where bias concentrates rather than whether it appears. These open-weight reasoning models reproduce the behavioural signature of human intergroup discrimination, independent of stereotype content, and social psychology's theories and methods offer a paradigm for measuring and governing AI's social behaviour.

physics.soc-ph↗
arXiv2019

Small worlds and clustering in spatial networks

Networks with underlying metric spaces attract increasing research attention in network science, statistical physics, applied mathematics, computer science, sociology, and other fields. This attention is further amplified by the current surge of activity in graph embedding. In the vast realm of spatial network models, only a few reproduce even the most basic properties of real-world networks. Here, we focus on three such properties--sparsity, small worldness, and clustering--and identify the general subclass of spatial homogeneous and heterogeneous network models that are sparse small worlds and that have nonzero clustering in the thermodynamic limit. We rely on the maximum entropy approach where network links correspond to noninteracting fermions whose energy dependence on spatial distances determines network small worldness and clustering.

physics.soc-ph↗