Absence of critical scaling in the Schelling segregation model

Abstract

We find no evidence of critical scaling in the Schelling segregation model, in either the Moore neighborhood or its dense-spectrum extension to Chebyshev radii up to $r_0 = 6$ ($k = 168$ neighbors). On periodic grids up to $L = 320$ with 50 trials per point (> 12,500 runs), every finite-size scaling diagnostic in the Moore baseline fails: the per-$L$ $T_c$ does not drift, Var$(S) \sim L^{-2.02 \pm 0.09}$ matches trivial averaging, $γ/ν\approx 0$, and the scaling collapse never reaches a finite optimum. The 8-site Moore neighborhood restricts satisfaction to ratios $j/k$ with $k \leq 8$, giving $S(T)$ a staircase structure with 23 rational thresholds; discreteness alone does not forbid criticality (cf. the Ising model), but the scaling evidence rules it out empirically. A branching-ratio calculation predicts subcritical cascades of mean size $1/(1-R)$ and is validated by perturbation experiments to within 15%; the multiscalar dissimilarity length stays finite across the transition. The dense-spectrum extension strengthens the negative verdict: across $r_0 \in {3,4,5,6}$ on $L \in {40,80,160}$ the Binder cumulant has no $L$-curve crossing and the per-$L$ $T_c$ drift is monotonic and unsaturated; at $r_0 = 4$, extending to $L = 320$ gives $α= -2.70$, below the critical boundary $α= -2$, dissolving an apparent $α= +0.81$ signal visible only on $L \in {40,80}$. The mechanism is the absence of long-range correlation in equilibrium plus deterministic high-$k$ dynamics, not the staircase structure. With a Beta-distributed heterogeneous tolerance, the intolerant tail drives segregation even at moderate population-average tolerance. The staircase theorem and cascade mechanism together account for the Schelling transition without invoking critical phenomena.