On the construction of geographical maps: Lagrange, Chebyshev, Darboux and Milnor

Abstract

Lagrange, Chebyshev, and Darboux, in 1779, 1856, and 1911, respectively, wrote articles all bearing the same title, \emph{On the Construction of Geographical Maps}. In 1969, Milnor wrote a paper in which he refers to Chebyshev's paper, of which he provides a new formulation and proof. In the present article, we review the results of all these papers, explaining the main ideas they contain and pointing out connections between them. We give complete proofs of the statements by Darboux and Milnor, both of which aim to make explicit and provide a proof of Chebyshev's result, but whose contents are different. Although Chebyshev did not state explicitly what the word ``best'' means, his conclusion, like that of Darboux and of Milnor, is that a best geographical map is characterised by the fact that its conformal factor is constant on the boundary of the region represented. Our statement and proof of Milnor's theorem work in a more general setting than the one he gives. The final version of this paper will appear in the Handbook of Mathematics in the Arts and Sciences (second edition), ed. Bharath Sriraman, Springer, 2027.