The extremal gap for scattered $q$-systems

Abstract

Two general estimates govern the rank of an $h$-scattered $q$-system: the scattered upper bound and the lower bound for systems maximal under inclusion. We determine exactly when they coincide. Besides $m=h+1$ and $m=h+2$, equality occurs precisely when $h$ is even, $m=h+3$, and $k\equiv h/2\pmod{h+1}$. We also prove rigidity in the first two cases: every extremal system is equivalent to either $\mathbb{F}_q^k$ or a direct sum of elementary Gabidulin systems and $\mathbb{F}_q$-directions. For $h=m-3$ and $k=\ell(m-2)+s$, with $1\leq s<(m-2)/2$, the two bounds differ by one, apart from one boundary case. Starting from an arbitrary maximum scattered $q$-system, we construct extremal quasi-maximum $(m-3)$-scattered systems of rank $\ell m+s$. Every such extension preserves lower bounds on the generalized rank weights of the initial code. When an explicit independence condition holds, the construction also produces a nondegenerate dual pair of quasi-MRD codes. We parametrize these extensions by subspaces of a quotient space and derive a uniform lower bound on the number of inequivalent outputs. Known order-two families yield codes separated from every nontrivial direct sum under an explicit numerical condition, while higher-order families are separated from a specified order-one direct-sum class. We conclude with a fully explicit binary example.