Kinematic scaling of thin and thick discs from SAMI to NewHorizon

Abstract

We revisit the relation between disc stellar mass and disc velocity dispersion (M_*-\sigma_e) and extend it to thin and thick subcomponents using orbit-based dynamical models of 161 SAMI galaxies and counterpart measurements for 31 disc galaxies in the NewHorizon simulation. On the observational side, we apply Schwarzschild orbit superposition to recover orbital circularity distributions and component kinematics. On the simulation side, we sample thin and thick discs by circularity and, separately, by stellar age to test classification dependence. Our analysis reveals three main results. (1) Discs follow a tight M_*-\sigma_e relation, nearly parallel to the bulge relation. (2) For both circularity- and age-based definitions, the thick-disc component is systematically hotter than the thin-disc component, and the thin-thick dispersion ratio varies only weakly with mass. However, age cuts yield a smaller kinematic contrast, indicating that stellar age and orbital circularity do not map one-to-one and that no single global age threshold reproduces the circularity-based split. (3) Method and data systematics are present, with Schwarzschild modelling returning slightly higher disc \sigma_e than spectroscopic bulge-disc decompositions, and simulated discs showing lower \sigma_e at fixed mass than observed. All these results are consistent with a baseline set by vertical-equilibrium scalings, with secular heating accumulating over time and modulating the dispersion at fixed mass. Occasional minor interactions may add localised heating but do not appear to be essential for explaining the qualitative, global trends reported here. Future tests with chemo-dynamical modelling and higher-resolution, chemistry-tracking simulations will provide stronger constraints on disc substructures in external galaxies.