Strong counterexamples to Mubayi's supersaturation conjecture in every uniformity

Abstract

The supersaturation problem asks, for a fixed $r$-graph $\mathcal F$, for the minimum number of copies of $\mathcal F$ in an $n$-vertex $r$-graph with $\ex(n,\mathcal F)+q$ edges. Mubayi conjectured a local form of supersaturation under a stability hypothesis: if $\mathcal F$ is non-$r$-partite and stable, meaning roughly that the extremal $\mathcal F$-free construction is unique and all near-extremal $\mathcal F$-free $r$-graphs are close to it, then this minimum should be at least $q c(n,\mathcal F)$, where $c(n,\mathcal F)$ is the minimum number of copies created by adding one edge to the extremal $\mathcal F$-free $r$-graph. We disprove this conjectured local lower bound in every uniformity. For every $r\ge2$ and every $K>1$, we construct a stable $r$-graph $\mathcal F$ such that, for all sufficiently large $n$ and every $1\le q\le δn$, there is an $n$-vertex $r$-graph with $\ex(n,\mathcal F)+q$ edges and at most $K^{-1}q c(n,\mathcal F)$ copies of $\mathcal F$. Thus the conjectured lower bound can already fail at $q=1$, and the failure can be by an arbitrarily large constant factor in every uniformity.