Radiatively Controlled Thermal Stability of High-Altitude Clouds in Exoplanetary Atmospheres

Abstract

One of the most striking findings of exoplanetary science is the ubiquity of clouds. A conventional approach to infer the cloud compositions is to utilize the thermochemical equilibrium model assuming the same temperature shared with clouds and ambient gases; however, this assumption is actually not always valid, especially in the tenuous upper atmospheres where particle-gas collisions are infrequent. In this study, we investigate the radiative equilibrium temperatures of exoplanetary clouds to assess the thermal stability of aerosols in the low atmospheric pressure limit. For eight cloud-forming condensates (KCl, ZnS, Na$_2$S, MnS, SiO$_2$, Mg$_2$SiO$_4$, Fe, and Al$_2$O$_3$), we solve the energy balance between stellar radiative heating and infrared cooling to calculate the particle temperature, which is then compared with their condensation temperatures. We find three composition-dependent groups in the particle-temperature behavior, and show that silicate condensates (SiO$_2$ and Mg$_2$SiO$_4$) maintain a cool enough temperature in a wide range of stellar and planetary conditions. Conversely, sulfide condensates (ZnS, Na$_2$S, and MnS) are readily heated to their sublimation temperatures even on temperate planets. WASP-17b and HD 189733b fall within the thermodynamically stable regime for SiO$_2$ clouds, consistent with recent JWST observations. We also examine the vertical profiles of cloud temperatures on WASP-17b, showing that Fe clouds cannot exist on the dayside, and Al$_2$O$_3$ clouds can exist only in a confined region, even though atmospheric temperature appears to allow the formation of these clouds. This study provides novel insights on cloud compositions in upper exoplanetary atmospheres, testable by upcoming atmospheric surveys of JWST and Ariel.