Nodal Braess's Paradox and Inertia Destabilization with Dynamic Node and Line Failures in Power Grids

Abstract

Large-scale power outages are typically caused by cascading failures. These unfold dynamically through complex interactions between network dynamics and individual component failures. In contrast, the study of cascading failures in physics has focused on analyzing line overloads in the quasi-static regime. We introduce a new model that integrates the dynamics of node and line failures with a paradigmatic oscillator model for power grid synchronization. This enables us to investigate the collective cascading behavior of coupled failures for the first time. We study the impact of nodal robustness, the ability of nodes to tolerate transient disturbances, and inertia, the ability of nodes to resist frequency deviations, on cascade sizes. We discover two novel mechanisms driving system fragility: i) While low inertia is widely considered a major challenge for power grids, we find that high inertia can amplify cascade sizes unless accompanied by appropriate adjustments of other dynamical properties. ii) Further, we find that an increase in the robustness of individual nodes can paradoxically lead to larger cascades. This latter phenomenon constitutes a novel type of Braess's paradox. Understanding such counterintuitive collective effects may become central for achieving resilient future power grids.