Minimax Synthesis of Network Mechanisms

Abstract

A single observed network reflects several mechanisms at once: communities, hubs, and clustering coexist in one graph, each a different model. We treat the network as a combination of candidate mechanisms and study, from a single graph, how strongly each mechanism contributes and how they combine. We address two questions. The first is how to measure each mechanism's contribution when the mechanisms must themselves be estimated from the graph: fitting the mechanisms and their strengths from the same data biases the strengths toward zero, and a correction removes this bias and yields valid confidence intervals. The second is whether the rule of combination is itself recoverable: when a graph is generated by two mechanisms acting together, the graph alone determines whether they combine additively or interact, exactly when the graph is dense enough, a sharp threshold below which no test can decide. The estimate calibrates the candidate mechanisms against the observed edges. We establish matching minimax rate, against a known-design benchmark and the estimated-design problem itself, confirm the methods in simulation, and apply them to real networks, where the signed coefficients recover known structure and, in one case, a confidence interval excludes any positive contribution from a candidate mechanism.