Fixed-Point Scaffolding in the Clef Programming Language

Abstract

For fans of Gabriel's "Worse is Better" it may be ironic that C++, by way of MLIR, serves as the scaffold for compiling an ML-family language whose correctness properties are structural. A crucial intersection in our Composer compiler initiates its lowering with a fixed-point combinator that preserves the dimensional, grade, escape, and numeric-representation structure from the Program Semantic Graph. And the MLIR that's witnessed from the PSG is no passive host. Its use of static single assignment, attribute system and dialects carry that structure materially. We show that our compiler middle end uses categorical construction for lowering code with companion verification to that strata: a functor from the compilation poset to a target category, subject to the compositionality equation. The grounding of our approach comes from three sources, each on its own algebraic object: Ohori's machine-code proof theory grounds the compilation axis, parametricity grounds the content at the base, and adjoint mode logic grounds the traversal between our verification tiers. To extend the thesis we introduce compact-closed negative and fractional types, and show the type machinery can be carried with preserved structure and realized through tooling MLIR provides. More broadly, the same fixed-point primitive that preserves types through compilation also supplies proof terms that can continue to be exercised in MLIR to verify its integrity as lowering proceeds through the pipeline. We argue that this foundation is a unique additional point anticipated by our framework that includes dimensional types, Tarau's groupoid, and cellular sheaves. Throughout, the formalism is instrumented as an internal scaffold: the abstractions support the compiler's mechanics, where a developer is never required to reach for category theory in order to rely on the guarantees the compiler provides.