Revisiting Bruck: Phase-Efficient All-to-All Collective Communication in Reconfigurable Networks

Abstract

All-to-All collective communication is a key performance bottleneck for distributed machine learning (ML) and high-performance computing (HPC) workloads, where dense traffic increasingly stresses scale-up interconnects. While these ML and HPC workloads have driven unprecedented infrastructure demand, optical reconfigurable networks (ORNs) offer a promising path forward as they can reconfigure the network at runtime. By adapting the physical topology to the active workload, they improve communication cost and bandwidth utilization. However, optical reconfigurable networks introduce a fundamental trade-off for collective communication: each reconfiguration requires global synchronization, during which communication is suspended for at a non-negligible delay. Additionally, their benefit is critically contingent on whether the collective consists of structured phases that can be served by sparse and reusable topology states. In this paper, we revisit Bruck's All-to-All implementation and demonstrate the benefits of topology optimization in which both communication pattern and reconfiguration strategy are co-designed. We present ReTri, a bidirectional All-to-All schedule for ORNs based on the Trivance algorithm. ReTri uses balanced ternary block propagation to complete All-to-All in $\lceil \log_3 n\rceil$ phases. The reconfiguration strategy induced by ReTri's pairwise bidirectional exchanges allows reconfiguration delays to be amortized across multiple phases. Preliminary simulations show that ReTri improves completion time by up to $10\times$ over Pairwise All-to-All, even for millisecond-scale reconfiguration delays, and improves reconfigurable Bruck by up to $2.1\times$.