The tale of the 3 planets: 3D cloud feedback enhances the spectral diversity of warm Jupiters

Abstract

JWST has shown a large diversity in warm Jupiter spectra, despite only small variations in the planetary parameters. However, the main driver of this diversity remains unclear. We aim to identify the mechanisms responsible for the spectral difference of three warm Jupiter-size exoplanets observed by JWST: whereas WASP-80b appears mostly cloud-free, both WASP-107b and WASP-69b have spectra dominated by clouds. We model each planet using the same framework, ADAM (formerly SPARC/MITgcm), which solves for the interactions among cloud transport, radiative transfer, and atmospheric circulation in 3D. We investigate the role of three condensate species, Na$_2$S, KCl, and MgSiO$_3$, and four particle sizes (0.1, 1, 5, and 10 $\mu$m). Clouds settle deeper in the atmosphere of the higher-gravity planet WASP-80b than in WASP-107b, reproducing their spectral difference naturally. For WASP-107b, three clouds can reproduce the NIRCam observations: 5 $\mu$m Na$_2$S, 1 $\mu$m KCl, and 5 $\mu$m MgSiO$_3$ models. However, these cannot match the scattering slope observed at shorter wavelengths in NIRISS and the possible silicate feature in the MIRI bandpass, suggesting a multi-modal distribution of clouds. Our model predicts that small silicate particles should be homogeneously distributed and thus cannot account for the difference between the two limb spectra in the MIRI bandpass. Finally, applying the same model to WASP-69b does not yield a partially cloudy dayside solution that fits the emission spectra, as proposed in a previous study. Coupling among 3D circulation, clouds, and radiative transfer can enhance the spectral diversity of warm Jupiter exoplanets, particularly through changes in cloudiness with gravity. The combination of multi-phase, wide-wavelength coverage and models that couple clouds, circulation, and radiative transfer is key to advancing our understanding of these new objects.