Analysis of non pharmaceutical interventions with SIR epidemic models: decreasing the infection peak vs. minimizing the epidemic size

Eric Rozán; Marcelo N Kuperman; Sebastián Bouzat

Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2604.08420

Analysis of non pharmaceutical interventions with SIR epidemic models: decreasing the infection peak vs. minimizing the epidemic size

Eric Rozán·Marcelo N Kuperman·Sebastián Bouzat

View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

This study investigates the influence of different types of non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) on epidemic progression using SIR compartmental models. We analyze the optimization of two distinct targets: the final epidemic size and the infection peak, particularly how they respond to variations in the initiation time of the NPIs. We derive analytical approximations for the critical points of the infection curve of the standard mean-field SIR model with NPIs, and for the epidemic size, enabling a systematic comparison. The analytical results reveal the existence of six different allowed scenarios for the evolution of the epidemic with a single NPI. Furthermore, by employing degree-based mean-field network models, we distinguish between NPIs that decrease the transmission rate (individual and environmental measures) and those that reduce social contacts (lock down measures). We find that, when assuming equal effects on the reproductive number, the former are more efficient in reducing the final epidemic size. Meanwhile, the effectivities of both types of NPIs differ in reducing primary and secondary peaks. The results for all models consistently confirm that minimizing the infection peak requires earlier implementation of the NPI than minimizing the epidemic size, offering new insights for strategic public health timing.

Explore related subjects

q-bio.PE physics.soc-ph

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeX RIS

Eric Rozán, Marcelo N Kuperman, Sebastián Bouzat. 2026-04-09. Analysis of non pharmaceutical interventions with SIR epidemic models: decreasing the infection peak vs. minimizing the epidemic size. https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.08420

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

Beta-coalescents when sample size is large

Sweepstakes reproduction refers to a highly skewed individual recruitment success without involving natural selection and may apply to individuals in broadcast spawning populations characterised by Type III survivorship. We consider an extension of the model of sweepstakes reproduction for a haploid panmictic population of constant size $N$; the extension also works as an alternative to the Wright-Fisher model. Our model incorporates an upper bound on the random number of potential offspring (juveniles) produced by a given individual. Depending on how the bound behaves relative to the total population size, we obtain the Kingman coalescent, an incomplete Beta-coalescent, or the (complete) Beta-coalescent. We argue that applying such an upper bound is biologically reasonable. Moreover, we estimate the error of the coalescent approximation. The error estimates reveal that convergence can be slow, and small sample size can be sufficient to invalidate convergence, for example if the stated bound is of the form $N/\log N$. We use simulations to investigate the effect of increasing sample size on the site-frequency spectrum. When the limit is a Beta-coalescent, the site frequency spectrum will be as predicted by the limiting tree even though the full coalescent tree may deviate from the limiting one. When in the domain of attraction of the Kingman coalescent the effect of increasing sample size depends on the effective population size as has been noted in the case of the Wright-Fisher model. Conditioning on the population ancestry (the random ancestral relations of the entire population at all times) may have little effect on the site-frequency spectrum for the models considered here (as evidenced by simulation results).

q-bio.PE↗

arXiv2026

The role of nestedness and saturating feedback in bipartite ecological systems

Large ecosystems balance competition and cooperation, yet standard generalized Lotka--Volterra models make mutualism destabilizing by amplifying disorder and driving unbounded growth. We show that Monod-like saturation resolves this paradox: dynamical mean-field theory and random-matrix analysis reveal a broader stable phase and enhanced survival. Network architecture provides a second control mechanism, but nestedness offers no intrinsic stability advantage. Instead, it is a byproduct of degree distributions with high connectivity necessary for stability.

q-bio.PE↗

arXiv2026

TreeFlow: probabilistic modelling and automatic differentiation for phylogenetics

Probabilistic modelling frameworks are powerful tools for statistical modelling and inference. They are not immediately generalizable to phylogenetic problems due to the particular computational properties of the phylogenetic tree object. TreeFlow is a software library for probabilistic modelling and automatic differentiation with phylogenetic trees. It embeds phylogenetic trees in the TensorFlow Probability framework, and implements inference algorithms for phylogenetic models given a fixed tree topology. We demonstrate how TreeFlow can be used to quickly implement and assess new models. We also show that it provides reasonable performance for gradient-based inference algorithms compared to specialized computational libraries for phylogenetics.

q-bio.PE↗