Statistical Flux Freezing with Magnetic Path-lines in Turbulence

Abstract

Magnetic flux freezing states that, in ideal magnetohydrodynamics, magnetic flux is transported by the flow and magnetic field lines remain frozen into the plasma. In turbulent plasmas, however, the velocity and magnetic fields are spatially rough, invalidating the regularity assumptions underlying the classical theorem. Previous work has shown that Lagrangian trajectories in such rough flows can become nonunique in the limit of small magnetic diffusivity, leading to stochastic formulations of magnetic flux freezing based on magnetic field lines. Field lines, however, are instantaneous geometric objects that do not possess a natural time evolution and do not preserve identity in turbulent flows. We instead use magnetic path lines, which remain intrinsically stochastic in the ideal limit, implying that magnetic flux is conserved only in a statistical sense over ensembles of backward-advected path-line surfaces. This yields a statistical formulation of Alfven's theorem in terms of magnetic path lines and shows that the classical deterministic form of flux freezing cannot hold in sufficiently rough turbulent magnetic fields. While closely related in physical content to earlier stochastic flux-freezing approaches based on magnetic field lines, the path-line formulation provides time-evolving dynamical trajectories that retain identity in spacetime and offer a simpler and more transparent framework for analyzing stochastic magnetic transport.