Near-optimality of conservative driving in discrete systems

Abstract

Transferring a physical system from an initial to a final state while minimizing energetic losses is an interdisciplinary control problem that bridges stochastic thermodynamics and optimal transport theory. Recent research typically considers problems in which the optimal solution is realized via conservative forces, but whether this situation applies depends on the problem's constraints. In systems with complex topologies like discrete networks, the optimal, dissipation-minimizing protocol involves applying nonconservative forces along cycles if the timescales of the transitions in the network are fixed. We show that although nonconservative driving is optimal in this setting, a conservative protocol always exists whose dissipation is at most 4/3 times the optimum. This finding is complemented with an example modeling transport across an energy barrier, which saturates this bound. We also prove near-optimality of conservative driving with a weaker numerical factor for a more general class of rate parametrizations with different load-sharing factors, stimulating the idea that optimality of nonconservative driving might be a generic phenomenon: As fewer degrees of freedom can be optimized, additional degrees of freedom due to adding nonconservative forces become more significant.