Universal circles for Anosov foliations

Abstract

Thurston introduced the notion of a universal circle associated to a taut foliation of a $3$-manifold as a way of organizing the ideal circle boundaries of its leaves into a single circle action. Calegari--Dunfield proved that every taut foliation of an atoroidal $3$-manifold $M$ has a universal circle, but the uniqueness (or lack-thereof) of this structure remains rather mysterious. In this paper, we consider the foliations associated to an Anosov flow $\varphi$ on $M$, showing that several constructions of a universal circle in the literature are typically distinct. Moreover, the underlying action of the Calegari--Dunfield leftmost universal circle is generally not even conjugate to the universal circle arising from the boundary of the flow space of $\varphi$. Our primary tool is a way to use the flow space of $\varphi$ to parameterize the circle bundle at infinity of $\varphi$'s invariant foliations.