Asking LLMs to Verify First is Almost Free Lunch

Abstract

To enhance the reasoning capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) without high costs of training, nor extensive test-time sampling, we introduce Verification-First (VF), a strategy that prompts models to verify a provided candidate answer, even a trivial or random one, before generating a solution. This approach triggers a "reverse reasoning" process complementary to standard forward Chain-of-Thought (CoT), which restricts the logical search space of the answer by pruning the LLM's output distribution. We further generalize VF prompting to Iter-VF, a sequential test-time scaling (TTS) method that iteratively cycles the verification-generation process using the model's previous answer. Extensive experiments across various benchmarks and various LLMs confirm that VF prompting with random answer consistently outperforms standard CoT with minimal computational overhead, and Iter-VF outperforms existing TTS strategies. VF is also effective on SOTA thinking models. For example, by using the simple VF prompting, we obtain a new SOTA 94.9% accuracy on GPQA-Diamond with Gemini-3-Pro-Preview where VF reduces its errors by ~30% relatively.