Unphysical Solutions in Coupled-Cluster-Based Random Phase Approximation and How to Avoid Them

Ruiheng Song; Xiliang Gong; Hong-Zhou Ye

Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2508.11051

Unphysical Solutions in Coupled-Cluster-Based Random Phase Approximation and How to Avoid Them

Ruiheng Song·Xiliang Gong·Hong-Zhou Ye

View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

The direct ring coupled-cluster doubles (drCCD)-based random phase approximation (RPA) has provided an attractive framework for the development and application of RPA-related methods. However, a potential unphysical solution issue recently reported by Rekkedal and co-workers (J. Chem. Phys. 139, 081101, 2013) has raised significant concerns regarding the general applicability of coupled-cluster-based RPA, particularly in small-gap systems where RPA is anticipated to outperform commonly employed second-order perturbation theory. In this work, we elucidate the underlying origin of the multi-solution issue in drCCD and develop both a practical criterion for validating drCCD solutions and improved preconditioners based on level shifting and regularized MP2 methods for stabilizing the iterative solution of the drCCD equation. We demonstrate the robustness and effectiveness of our approach through representative systems -- including molecules with stretched bonds, large conjugated systems, and metallic clusters -- where standard drCCD iteration encounters convergence difficulties. Furthermore, we extend our approach to various recently developed reduced-scaling drCCD-based RPA methods, thereby establishing a foundation for their stable application to large-scale problems. The extension of our approach to RPA with exchange, quasiparticle RPA, and particle-particle RPA is also discussed.

Explore related subjects

physics.chem-ph cond-mat.mtrl-sci

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeX RIS

Ruiheng Song, Xiliang Gong, Hong-Zhou Ye. 2025-08-14. Unphysical Solutions in Coupled-Cluster-Based Random Phase Approximation and How to Avoid Them. https://arxiv.org/abs/2508.11051

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

Construction of downfolded Hamiltonians from projective transcorrelation

Projective transcorrelation recovers the short-range electron correlation by a similarity transformation with a geminal function $f(r_{12})$, at the cost of an effective Hamiltonian containing a 3-body term. We replace the term by an effective operator of rank at most two, obtained from the two-body cumulant (2C) approximation to the three-particle reduced density matrix. The 2C 3-body energy is written without cumulants, and the effective one- and two-body interactions are derived as its partial derivatives with respect to the reduced density matrices. The truncation is assessed on the atomization and reaction energies of the HEAT set with CCSD(T), and on the CAS-pTC model, whose downfolded Hamiltonian is held on a qubit register with the number of Pauli strings reduced from the sixth power of the orbital count to the fourth.

physics.chem-ph↗

arXiv2026

Competing Ring-Opening and Hofmann Elimination Pathways in Aqueous TEMPO Catholytes: A First-Principles Study

Aqueous redox-flow batteries based on TEMPO derivatives are promising for large-scale energy storage, but their practical use is limited by the chemical instability of the oxidized N -oxoammonium state. In this work, we investigate the degradation of five TEMPO derivatives using ab initio molecular dynamics combined with enhanced sampling. Two proposed degradation mechanisms, ring opening and Hofmann elimination, are examined and their corresponding activation free energies are compared. For all derivatives considered, ring opening exhibits a lower activation free energy than Hofmann elimination, identifying it as the kinetically preferred degradation pathway. The magnitude of the ring-opening barrier, however, varies significantly between molecules, showing that different functionalizations strongly influence its stability toward degradation. The predicted preference for ring opening is consistent with available experimental studies, which have identified or inferred ring-opening degradation for several TEMPO-based catholytes. These results provide an atomistic picture of degradation pathways that are difficult to resolve experimentally and highlight the importance of molecular structure in controlling the kinetic stability of TEMPO derivatives in aqueous electrolytes.

physics.chem-ph↗

arXiv2026

Exchange-Correlation Potentials and Energies from Inverse Generalized Kohn-Sham Calculations

The Kohn-Sham (KS) formulation of density functional theory (DFT) is a map from the many-electron problem to an effective single-electron problem that is governed by a local multiplicative potential. The generalized-Kohn-Sham (GKS) formalism extends it to permit any single-electron operator---nonlocal, local non-multiplicative, local multiplicative, or any combination of them. Doing so expands the scope and ease of modeling the exchange-correlation (XC) functional in DFT, which encodes the complicated many-electron interactions into a mean-field of the electron density. However, unlike KS theory, development of XC functionals in GKS theory has been hindered by the absence of corresponding exact XC potentials and energies. We present the exact XC potentials and energies for atoms and molecules by solving the inverse GKS problem, using highly accurate correlated \textit{ab initio} densities. Our approach is validated across weakly and strongly correlated systems. We further examine a common, yet untested, assumption that KS and GKS correlation potentials and energies are similar, finding instead that they differ substantially in strongly correlated systems. Overall, this work offers a powerful tool to model next-generation of XC functionals within the GKS formalism of DFT.

physics.chem-ph↗