arXiv Science⌕ Search
Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2508.05961

K2-18b Does Not Meet The Standards of Evidence For Life

Kevin B. Stevenson·Jacob Lustig-Yaeger·E. M. May·Ravi K. Kopparapu·Thomas J. Fauchez·Jacob Haqq-Misra·Mary Anne Limbach·Edward W. Schwieterman·Kristin S. Sotzen·Shang-Min Tsai
View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

K2-18b, a temperate sub-Neptune, has garnered significant attention due to claims of possible biosignatures in its atmosphere. Low-confidence detections of dimethyl sulfide (DMS) and/or dimethyl disulfide (DMDS) have sparked considerable debate, primarily around arguments that their absorption features are not uniquely identifiable. Here, we consider all five questions from the astrobiology standards of evidence framework, starting with: Have we detected an authentic signal? To answer this, we analyzed publicly-available JWST observations of K2-18b using independent data reduction and spectral retrieval methodologies. Our comprehensive set of reductions demonstrates that the MIRI transit spectrum is highly susceptible to unresolved instrumental systematics. Applying different wavelength binning schemes yields a potpourri of planet spectra that then lead to a wide assortment of atmospheric interpretations. Consequently, we offer recommendations to help minimize this previously-underappreciated instrument systematic in future MIRI reductions of any exoplanet. While the MIRI binning scheme adopted by Madhusudhan et al. (2025) favors the presence of DMS/DMDS in K2-18b, we find that 87.5% of retrievals using our preferred MIRI binning scheme do not. When considering the full, 0.7 - 12 micron transit spectrum, we confirm the detection of CH4 and favor CO2, and find the presence of DMS and C2H4 to be interchangeable. Moreover, we find that the tentative presence of large features in the MIRI transit spectrum is in tension with the more robust, yet smaller, features observed in the near IR. We conclude that red noise -- rather than an astrophysical signal -- plagues the mid-IR data and there is, as yet, no statistically significant evidence for biosignatures in the atmosphere of K2-18b.

Explore related subjects

astro-ph.EPastro-ph.IM

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Kevin B. Stevenson, Jacob Lustig-Yaeger, E. M. May, Ravi K. Kopparapu, Thomas J. Fauchez, Jacob Haqq-Misra, Mary Anne Limbach, Edward W. Schwieterman, Kristin S. Sotzen, Shang-Min Tsai. 2025-09-03. K2-18b Does Not Meet The Standards of Evidence For Life. https://arxiv.org/abs/2508.05961

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

Strict Limits on Helium Absorption from LHS 1140 b from Four JWST NIRISS Transits

Orbiting in the habitable zone of its host star, the 1.7 $R_\oplus$, 5.6 $M_\oplus$ planet LHS 1140 b is a target of great interest. Recently Cherubim et al. (2026) published a detection of metastable He escaping from the atmosphere of LHS 1140 b, simultaneously providing the first concrete inference of an atmosphere on this planet and indicating that the atmosphere is He-rich and H-poor as would be expected due to Gyrs of fractionated mass loss. In this work, we analyze four archival transits of LHS 1140 b, spanning Dec 2023 to Jul 2026, taken with the NIRISS instrument on JWST, for evidence of He absorption. Each of the four visits disfavours the presence of He absorption compared to a flat continuum with odds ratios ranging from 3.9--11.6:1. He absorption with an amplitude and width equivalent to that observed by Cherubim et al. (2026) is strongly ruled out by the data with odds ratios from 300--8.6$\times$10$^4$:1 compared to a flat continuum --- though it should be noted that none of the JWST transits are contemporaneous with the Cherubim et al. (2026) detection. We also fit the absolute out-of-transit stellar spectra from these four visits, as well as an additional JWST NIRISS transit of planet c, to search for evidence of stellar variability, but find consistent photosphere and herterogeneity parameters in all five datasets. In all, our work provides a set of strict limits on He escape from LHS 1140 b that will be valuable to future studies into the nature and evolution of this intriguing world.

astro-ph.EP↗
arXiv2026

Bridging magnetothermal winds and photoevaporation to model discs dispersal

Protoplanetary disc dispersal is driven by two processes usually modelled separately: photoevaporative and magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) disc winds. Global simulations indicate that in the inner disc these are not distinct outflows but a single magnetothermal wind. We assemble a closed-form, two-phase model that respects it. A single-field-line wind, whose base is fixed by the irradiated temperature and penetration column, supplies the launch and feeds a secular evolution, with photoevaporation convolved on as a sink. The flux closure $B_z\proptoΣ^q$ is self-limiting: for $q\le1/2$ depletion alone cannot demagnetise the disc, so dispersal requires independent flux loss, parameterised by the magnetic Reynolds number $\mathcal{R}_m$. Integrating the coupled system yields two regimes. Efficient flux loss ($\mathcal{R}_m\lesssim1$) lets the magnetisation front recede by over an order of magnitude and opens a photoevaporative gap. Flux retention ($\mathcal{R}_m\gg1$) drives the front outward, sustains accretion, and defers dispersal by $\approx2.7$~Myr. Deriving the base from stellar irradiation instead of prescribing it, we find that the cold-launch approximation is valid during the early stages of disc evolution: anchoring the base at plasma equipartition ($β_{\rm base} \sim 1$) confines irradiation's influence on the magnetic lever arm to the magnetothermal annulus, decoupling the peak accretion rate from the incident flux. Both regimes clear the disc inside-out, through either a photoevaporatively amplified cavity wall or an expanding magnetothermal front.

astro-ph.EP↗
arXiv2026

Faithful Neural Embeddings for 3D Exoplanet Climate Modeling

With the rapid advancement of telescopes like JWST and Ariel, there is an urgent need for efficient 3D climate models to interpret observations of exoplanet atmospheres. Traditional 3D general circulation models (GCMs) are computationally intensive, prompting the development of machine learning (ML) emulators to accelerate simulations. Recent work, such as that by Plaschzug et al. 2026 \cite{plaschzug2026accelerating}, uses a dense neural network (DNN) to predict local gas temperatures and winds from input parameters, including local gas pressure, spatial coordinates (longitude and latitude), and global temperature. However, this model relies on predicting individual temperature values (points) at specific grid points, which can be limited by the resolution and constraints of the training grid. In this work, we investigate a couple of alternative frameworks based on latent-space representations of local gas temperature ($\text{T}_{\text{gas}}$) to obtain a faithful, low-dimensional representation of these profiles. This represents the first step toward developing a latent space regression model, offering a structurally cohesive alternative to the existing point-wise prediction method \cite{plaschzug2026accelerating}. By capturing the optimal embedding space of atmospheric data, our proposed framework can produce simulated profiles while maintaining computational efficiency, making it suitable for large-scale exoplanet ensemble studies.

astro-ph.EP↗