arXiv Science⌕ Search
Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2508.01645

Local compactness does not always imply spatiality

G. Bezhanishvili·S. D. Melzer·R. Raviprakash·A. L. Suarez
View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

It is a well-known result in pointfree topology that every locally compact frame is spatial. Whether this result extends to MT-algebras (McKinsey-Tarski algebras) was an open problem. We resolve it in the negative by constructing a locally compact sober MT-algebra which is not spatial. We also revisit Nöbeling's largely overlooked approach to pointfree topology from the 1950s. We show that his separation axioms are closely related to those in the theory of MT-algebras with the notable exception of Hausdorffness. We prove that Nöbeling's Spatiality Theorem implies the well-known Isbell Spatiality Theorem. We then generalize Nöbeling's Spatiality Theorem by proving that each locally compact $T_{1/2}$-algebra is spatial. The proof utilizes the fact that every nontrivial $T_{1/2}$-algebra contains a closed atom, which we show is equivalent to the axiom of choice.

Explore related subjects

math.GN

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

G. Bezhanishvili, S. D. Melzer, R. Raviprakash, A. L. Suarez. 2025-08-03. Local compactness does not always imply spatiality. https://arxiv.org/abs/2508.01645

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

Homogeneous linearly ordered spaces

Every compact subset of a homogeneous generalized ordered (GO) space has character at most $ω_1$ and cardinality at most $2^{ω_1}$; if such a subset has uncountable character, then the character of the whole space equals $ω_1$ and its $π$-character is countable. We construct a homogeneous $σ$-compact linearly ordered space (LOTS) $\mathbf{H}$ containing a compact subset $\mathbf{S}$ of cardinality $2^{ω_1}$ whose character is $ω_1$ at every point and whose weight and Souslin number are both $2^{ω_1}$; thus both bounds obtained are sharp. We prove that a semitopological group that is a GO space is hereditarily paracompact; if, in addition, it is not a $P$-space, then it is submetrizable, has countable character, and its compact subsets are metrizable. Every linearly ordered semitopological group (and, more generally, every GO semitopological group) is either metrizable or is a $P$-space; the same holds for topological groups. We also show that in an order-homogeneous LOTS every compact subset is first countable.

math.GN↗
arXiv2026

A New Approach to Universal Measurability

V. Fedorchuk, A. Chizogidze, and T. Banakh in 2003 and V. Bogachev in 2024 posed the following questions: (i) is it true that $P_τ(X)$ is $C$-embedded in $P_σ(X)$; (ii) Is it true that $P_R(X)$ is $C$-embedded in $P_R(βX)$ if and only if $X$ is pseudocompact, where $P_σ$, $P_τ$, and $P_R$ are the functors of probability $σ$-additive on the Baire $σ$-algebra, $τ$-additive, and Radon measures on the space $X$? The answers to these questions are negative. However, if instead of probability measures we consider the corresponding alternating measures $M_σ$, $M_τ$, and $M_R$, the situation changes. It is proved that (i) $M_τ(X)$ is $C$-embedded in $M_σ(X)$; (ii) $M_R(X)$ is $C$-embedded in $M_R(βX)$ if and only if $X$ is pseudocompact. The question of $C$-embedding of measure spaces is an extension of the question of coincidence of measure spaces, which is a development of the classical concepts of universally measurable and universal measure zero sets. A general theorem is obtained, which leads to the mentioned results.

math.GN↗
arXiv2026

One-Point Metrizable Coarsenings: Gauges and Local Metric Preservation

Let $(X,τ)$ be metrizable and let $a\in X$. We give a constructive account of metrizable topologies $σ\subseteqτ$ that agree with $τ$ on $X\setminus\{a\}$. Applying Hausdorff's classical metric collapse construction, for every noncompact $(X,τ)$ and every compatible metric $d$ we obtain a strict coarsening with a metric $p\le d$ that agrees with $d$ on a common neighborhood of each point other than $a$. A prescribed countably infinite closed discrete set $\{x_n:n\in\N\}\subseteq X\setminus\{a\}$ can be made to satisfy $p(a,x_n)\leλ_n$ for any positive null sequence $(λ_n)$. The resulting metric is greatest among the metrics dominated by $d$ that satisfy these bounds, and is complete whenever $d$ is complete. We exhibit its realization as a classical metric quotient. We also represent all localized metrizable coarsenings by continuous scalar gauges using a standard cone metric. Inclusion is expressed by the cofinal comparison of sublevel sets familiar from extension-trace theory, while pointwise maximum and minimum realize finite joins and meets. A closed-discrete criterion detects strictness. Standard preservation results for Borel structure, complete metrizability, and Polishness, together with function-space and local-field examples, complete the account.

math.GN↗