SZ Sequences: Binary-Based $(0, 2^q)$-Sequences

Abstract

Low-discrepancy sequences have seen widespread adoption in computer graphics thanks to their superior convergence rates. Since rendering integrals often comprise products of lower-dimensional integrals, recent work has focused on developing sequences that are also well-distributed in lower-dimensional projections. To this end, we introduce a novel construction of binary-based (0, 4)-sequences; that is, progressive fully multi-stratified sequences of 4D points, and extend the idea to higher power-of-two dimensions. We further show that not only it is possible to nest lower-dimensional sequences in higher-dimensional ones -- for example, embedding a (0, 2)-sequence within our (0, 4)-sequence -- but that we can ensemble two (0, 2)-sequences into a (0, 4)-sequence, four (0, 4)-sequences into a (0, 16)-sequence, and so on. Such sequences can provide excellent convergence rates when integrals include lower-dimensional integration problems in 2, 4, 16, ... dimensions. Our construction is based on using 2$\times$2 block matrices as symbols to construct larger matrices that potentially generate a sequence with the target (0, s)-sequence in base $s$ property. We describe how to search for suitable alphabets and identify two distinct, cross-related alphabets of block symbols, which we call S and Z, hence \emph{SZ} for the resulting family of sequences. Given the alphabets, we construct candidate generator matrices and search for valid sets of matrices. We then infer a formula to construct full-resolution (64-bit) matrices. Our binayr generator matrices allow highly efficient implementation using bitwise operations, and can be used as a drop-in replacement for Sobol matrices in existing applications. We compare SZ sequences to state-of-the-art low discrepancy sequences, and demonstrate mean relative squared error improvements up to $1.93\times$ in common rendering applications.