Hölder curves with exotic tangent spaces

Abstract

An important implication of Rademacher's Differentiation Theorem is that every Lipschitz curve $Γ$ infinitesimally looks like a line at almost all of its points in the sense that at $\mathcal{H}^1$-almost every point of $Γ$, the only tangent to $Γ$ is a straight line through the origin. In this article, we show that, in contrast, the infinitesimal structure of Hölder curves can be much more extreme. First we show that for every $s>1$ there exists a $(1/s)$-Hölder curve $Γ_s$ in a Euclidean space with $\mathcal{H}^s(Γ_s)>0$ such that $\mathcal{H}^s$-almost every point of $Γ_s$ admits infinitely many topologically distinct tangents. Second, we study the tangents of self-similar connected sets (which are canonical examples of Hölder curves) and prove that the curves $Γ_s$ have the additional property that $\mathcal{H}^s$-almost every point of $Γ_s$ admits infinitely many homeomorphically distinct tangents to $Γ_s$ which are not admitted as (not even bi-Lipschitz to) tangents to any self-similar set at typical points.