Evolutionary game with stochastic payoffs in a finite island model

Abstract

In this paper, we consider a two-player two-strategy game with random payoffs in a population subdivided into $d$ demes, each containing $N$ individuals at the beginning of any given generation and experiencing local extinction and recolonization with some fixed probability $m$ after reproduction and selection among offspring. Within each deme, offspring engage in random pairwise interactions, and the payoffs are assumed to have means and variances proportional to the inverse of the population size. By verifying the conditions given in Ethier and Nagylaki (1980) to approximate Markov chains with two time scales, we establish that the discrete-time evolutionary dynamics with $Nd$ generations as unit of time converges to a continuous-time diffusion as $d\rightarrow\infty$. The infinitesimal mean and variance of this diffusion are expressed in terms of the population-scaled means and variances of the payoffs besides identity-by-descent measures between offspring in the same deme in a neutral population. We show that the probability for a strategy to fix in the population starting from an initial frequency $(Nd)^{-1}$ generally increases as the payoffs to that strategy exhibit less variability or the payoffs to the other strategy more variability. As a result, differences in variability can make this fixation probability for cooperation larger than the corresponding one for defection. As the deme-scaled extinction rate $ν=mN$ decreases for $N$ large enough and $m$ small enough, creating a higher level of identity among offspring within demes, the differences between the population-scaled variances of the payoffs for interacting offspring of different types increases this effect to a greater extent than the differences for interacting offspring of the same type.