Evidence against a strong first-order phase transition in neutron star cores: impact of new data

Abstract

With the aim of exploring the evidence for or against phase transitions in cold and dense baryonic matter, the inference of the sound speed and equation-of-state for dense matter in neutron stars is extended in view of recent new observational data. The impact of the heavy (2.35 $M_\odot$) black widow pulsar PSR J0952-0607 and of the unusually light supernova remnant HESS J1731-347 is inspected. In addition a detailed re-analysis is performed of the low-density constraint based on chiral effective field theory and of the perturbative QCD constraint at asymptotically high densities, in order to clarify the influence of these constraints on the inference procedure. The trace anomaly measure, $\Delta = 1/3 - P/\varepsilon$, is also computed and discussed. A systematic Bayes factor assessment quantifies the evidence (or non-evidence) of low averaged sound speeds $(c_s^2 \leq 0.1)$, a prerequisite for a phase transition, within the range of densities realized in the core of neutron stars. One of the consequences of including PSR J0952-0607 in the data base is a further stiffening of the equation-of-state, resulting for a 2.1 solar-mass neutron star in a reduced central density of less than five times the equilibrium density of normal nuclear matter at the 68\% level. The evidence against small sound speeds in neutron star cores is further strengthened. Within the inferred 68\% posterior credible bands, only a weak first-order phase transition with a coexistence density interval $\Delta n/n \lesssim 0.2$ would be compatible with the observed data.