Live Programming for Finite Model Finders

Abstract

Finite model finders give users the ability to specify properties of a system in mathematical logic and then automatically find concrete examples, called solutions, that satisfy the properties. These solutions are often viewed as a key benefit of model finders, as they create an exploratory environment for developers to engage with their model. In practice, users find less benefit from these solutions than expected. For years, researchers believed that the problem was that too many solutions are produced. However, a recent user study found that users actually prefer enumerating a broad set of solutions. Inspired by a recent user study on Alloy, a modeling language backed by a finite model finder, we believe that the issue is that solutions are too removed from the logical constraints that generate them to help users build an understanding of the constraints themselves. In this paper, we outline a proof-of-concept for live programming of Alloy models in which writing the model and exploring solutions are intertwined. We highlight how this development environment enables more productive feedback loops between the developer, the model and the solutions.