Geometric Batch Optimization for the Packing Equal Circles in a Circle Problem on Large Scale

Abstract

The problem of packing equal circles in a circle is a classic and famous packing problem, which is well-studied in academia and has a variety of applications in industry. This problem is computationally challenging, and researchers mainly focus on small-scale instances with the number of circular items n less than 320 in the literature. In this work, we aim to solve this problem on large scale. Specifically, we propose a novel geometric batch optimization method that not only can significantly speed up the convergence process of continuous optimization but also reduce the memory requirement during the program's runtime. Then we propose a heuristic search method, called solution-space exploring and descent, that can discover a feasible solution efficiently on large scale. Besides, we propose an adaptive neighbor object maintenance method to maintain the neighbor structure applied in the continuous optimization process. In this way, we can find high-quality solutions on large scale instances within reasonable computational times. Extensive experiments on the benchmark instances sampled from n = 300 to 1,000 show that our proposed algorithm outperforms the state-of-the-art algorithms and performs excellently on large scale instances. In particular, our algorithm found 10 improved solutions out of the 21 well-studied moderate scale instances and 95 improved solutions out of the 101 sampled large scale instances. Furthermore, our geometric batch optimization, heuristic search, and adaptive maintenance methods are general and can be adapted to other packing and continuous optimization problems.