A simpler explanation of the reflective properties of conic sections, by following light rays along local isosceles paths

Abstract

Ellipses, parabolas and hyperbolas all have beautiful reflective properties. However, an intuitive explanation for why they have those properties has been lacking. There exist many mathematical proofs, but they tend to involve several analytical steps or geometrical constructions, making them unintuitive and hard to understand. Here, a simpler explanation is presented which only requires following the paths of light rays, and examining local paths that move from one point on a conic to a nearby one. First, a light-ray is followed as it runs along one of the legs of an isosceles triangle, and then reflects off a mirror that is parallel to the triangle's base. It bounces back along the path of the triangle's other leg. Next, a path is examined, moving from an arbitrary point on a conic section curve to a nearby point on the same curve. This path consists of two equal-length straight line steps, with each step following one of the constraints that defines the curve. For example, on an ellipse, defined by the sum of the distances to the two foci remaining constant, the path starts at a point on the ellipse, moves a distance delta directly away from one focus, then makes a second equal-length step directly towards the second focus. These two steps form the legs of precisely the sort of isosceles triangle described above, with its base running along the path of the curve. A light ray following the legs of that triangle gets reflected directly from one focus to the other. As the triangle shrinks towards zero, the reflection point converges onto the actual curve. Exactly the same argument also explains the reflections of parabolas and hyperbolas. Surprisingly, this explanation does not seem to have appeared previously in the long history of writings about conics. It is hoped that it will help to make the reflective properties of conic sections easier to understand and to explain.