A Critique of Sopin's "${\rm PH} = {\rm PSPACE}$"

Michael C. Chavrimootoo; Ian Clingerman; Quan Luu

Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2301.03487

A Critique of Sopin's "${\rm PH} = {\rm PSPACE}$"

Michael C. Chavrimootoo·Ian Clingerman·Quan Luu

View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

We critique Valerii Sopin's paper "${\rm PH} = {\rm PSPACE}$" [Sop14]. The paper claims to resolve one of the major open problems of theoretical computer science by leveraging the Skolemization of existential quantifiers of quantified boolean formulas to show that ${\rm QBF}$ (a well-known ${\rm PSPACE}$-complete problem) is in $\Pi_4^p$, and thus ${\rm PH} = {\rm PSPACE}$. In this critique, we highlight problems in that paper and conclude that it fails to establish that ${\rm PH} = {\rm PSPACE}$.

Explore related subjects

cs.CC

Keep this discovery

BibTeX RIS

Michael C. Chavrimootoo, Ian Clingerman, Quan Luu. 2022-12-09. A Critique of Sopin's "${\rm PH} = {\rm PSPACE}$". https://arxiv.org/abs/2301.03487

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

The Computational Complexity of Holant Problems on 4-regular Graphs from the Stable Subgroup Sequence of $SL(2,\mathbb{C})$

The Holant framework provides a general setting for studying counting problems and includes graph homomorphisms (\#GH) and counting constraint satisfaction problems (\#CSP) as special cases. Over the past twenty years, a series of computational complexity dichotomies have been established for Holant problems, but the classification for complex-valued signatures is still open. The main obstacle is the case in which all signatures have even arity. In this paper, we establish a dichotomy for Holant problems with a complex-valued 4-ary signature, which is a key base case for the full classification of Holant problems. We present a new strategy by introducing Schur's theorem, the classification of finite subgroups of $\mathrm{SL}(2,\mathbb{C})$ and stable subgroup sequences into the proof. These new techniques are of independent interest.

cs.CC↗

arXiv2026

Max Independent Set Remains NP-hard when Excluding a Planar Induced Minor

We show that there is a fixed planar graph $H$, namely the $5 \times 5$ grid, such that Max Independent Set remains NP-hard in $H$-induced-minor-free graphs. This refutes the Dallard--Milani\v{c}--\v{S}torgel conjecture and a weakening of it by Gartland and Lokshtanov, and by Korhonen.

cs.CC↗

arXiv2026

Topology inside NC$^1$

We show that ACC$^0$ is precisely what can be computed with constant-width circuits of polynomial size and polylogarithmic genus. This extends a characterization given by Hansen, showing that planar constant-width circuits also characterize ACC$^0$. Thus polylogarithmic genus provides no additional computational power in this model. We consider other generalizations of planarity, including crossing number and thickness. We show that constant-width circuits of polynomial size and thickness two already suffice to capture all of NC$^1$.

cs.CC↗