arXiv Science⌕ Search
Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2212.08431

Comment on "Analog Schwarzschild-like geometry in fluids with external pressure''

João Paulo M. Pitelli·Ricardo A. Mosna·Christyan C. de Oliveira·Maurício Richartz
View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

In Ref. [1], exact (not only conformally related) analogue models for the Schwarzschild and Reissner-Nordström spacetimes were found. The background non-relativistic fluid flow was sustained by an external body force which is not affected by the linearised fluctuations. Following a different route, by modelling the external force as the gradient of an external pressure, it was shown in~\cite{bilic} that the speed of sound is significantly modified. This effective speed of sound turns out to be inconsistent with the continuity equation. In this comment we analyse these two contradictory conclusions. We first show that the heuristic justification for the introduction of the external force via a variational principle given in Ref. [2] is conceptually incorrect. Then, by adding the external force appropriately, we show that the conclusions in [1] remain valid.

Explore related subjects

gr-qc

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

João Paulo M. Pitelli, Ricardo A. Mosna, Christyan C. de Oliveira, Maurício Richartz. 2022-12-16. Comment on "Analog Schwarzschild-like geometry in fluids with external pressure''. https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.106.108501

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

Quasinormal-mode residues and pole coalescence in hypergeometric black-hole models

We study source-normalized quasinormal-mode residues in radial boundary-value problems reducible to the Gauss hypergeometric equation. Hypergeometric connection coefficients separate the spectral condition from the normalization and spatial dependence of the frequency-domain Green function. We illustrate this construction for Dirichlet modes of the rotating Bañados--Teitelboim--Zanelli black hole and mixed boundary conditions in two-dimensional anti-de Sitter spacetime, and then apply it to the Pöschl--Teller/Nariai problem. Near pole coalescence, we obtain finite-position residues for the two simple poles, while at the critical point both coefficients of the second-order Laurent expansion are reduced to closed finite sums. The subleading coefficient depends explicitly on the frequency derivative of the Green-function numerator and is therefore not determined by the spectral function alone. We also identify the range in which the usual vanishing-discriminant criterion characterizes the Pöschl--Teller coalescence: it holds for the positive barrier considered here, whereas other double zeros or cancellations can occur outside that regime. These results provide a normalization-controlled analytic benchmark for relating spectral coalescence to sourced quasinormal response.

gr-qc↗
arXiv2026

Conservation law of super-Lorentz charges across spatial infinity

Under assumptions compatible with generic gravitational scattering, the vacuum relativistic gravitational field is entirely determined at leading order in the large radius expansion at spatial infinity by its supermomentum, its dual supermomentum and its global supertranslation frame. At subleading order, the gravitational field is determined by three additional sets of charges: the super-Lorentz charges, the leading mixed tail/ peeling-breaking charges and the leading peeling-breaking charges. In this work we provide a proper-supertranslation-invariant definition of these charges in terms of asymptotic Bondi-Sachs fields as well as a corresponding proper supertranslation and logarithmic translation invariant definition of these charges in terms of Beig-Schmidt fields. Using the properties of homogeneous and inhomogeneous solutions to relevant wave equations over the boundary de Sitter spacetime at spatial infinity, we derive the conservation law of super-Lorentz charges between the future and past of spatial infinity. We obtain that the super-Lorentz aspects are non-locally defined from the Bondi-Sachs fields.

gr-qc↗
arXiv2026

Oscillations of Dissipative Neutron Stars: The Impact of Hyperonic Reaction Rates

Tidal excitations of stellar oscillation modes during binary neutron-star inspirals offer a powerful probe of the composition of dense matter at supranuclear densities. Chemical equilibration plays a crucial, but often neglected, role in stellar perturbation calculations. If the chemical equilibration timescale is comparable to the oscillation timescale, then viscous effects can damp the modes. If the reactions are fast, some modes can completely disappear since their restoring force vanishes. Typically, these calculations, however, assume either instantaneous chemical equilibrium or no equilibration (frozen composition). Motivated by this, we investigate the effects of finite reaction rates on the oscillation spectrum of neutron stars containing hyperonic matter. We calculate the dominant non-leptonic weak interaction rates and incorporate them into the relativistic perturbation equations through a complex, frequency-dependent dynamical sound speed. We show that finite-rate effects naturally manifest as bulk-viscous dissipation, modifying the properties of both the fundamental ($f$) and gravity ($g$) modes. We further examine the impact on the tidal response by matching stellar perturbations to near-zone boundary conditions, demonstrating how viscous dissipation gives rise to a tidal lag. These results provide a consistent framework connecting microscopic reaction rates and the resulting bulk viscosity to the tidal dynamics of compact binaries, and represent a step towards incorporating viscous dissipation into gravitational-wave models of binary neutron-star inspirals.

gr-qc↗