Reproducibility of the Standard Model of diffusion in white matter on clinical MRI systems

Abstract

Estimating intra- and extra-axonal microstructure parameters, such as volume fractions and diffusivities, has been one of the major efforts in brain microstructure imaging with MRI. The Standard Model (SM) of diffusion in white matter has unified various modeling approaches based on impermeable narrow cylinders embedded in locally anisotropic extra-axonal space. However, estimating the SM parameters from a set of conventional diffusion MRI (dMRI) measurements is ill-conditioned. Multidimensional dMRI helps resolve the estimation degeneracies, but there remains a need for clinically feasible acquisitions that yield robust parameter maps. Here we find optimal multidimensional protocols by minimizing the mean-squared error of machine learning-based SM parameter estimates for two 3T scanners with corresponding gradient strengths of $40$ and $80\,\unit{mT/m}$. We assess intra-scanner and inter-scanner repeatability for 15-minute optimal protocols by scanning 20 healthy volunteers twice on both scanners. The coefficients of variation all SM parameters except free water fraction are $\lesssim 10\%$ voxelwise and $1-4 \%$ for their region-averaged values. As the achieved SM reproducibility outcomes are similar to those of conventional diffusion tensor imaging, our results enable robust in vivo mapping of white matter microstructure in neuroscience research and in the clinic.