Disjunction and existence properties in modal arithmetic

Abstract

We systematically study several versions of the disjunction and the existence properties in modal arithmetic. First, we newly introduce three classes $\mathrm{B}$, $\Delta(\mathrm{B})$, and $\Sigma(\mathrm{B})$ of formulas of modal arithmetic, and study basic properties of them. Then, we prove several implications between the properties. In particular, among other things, we prove that for any consistent recursively enumerable extension $T$ of $\mathbf{PA}(\mathbf{K})$ with $T \nvdash \Box \bot$, the $\Sigma(\mathrm{B})$-disjunction property, the $\Sigma(\mathrm{B})$-existence property, and the $\mathrm{B}$-existence property are pairwise equivalent. Moreover, we introduce the notion of the $\Sigma(\mathrm{B})$-soundness of theories, and prove that for any consistent recursively enumerable extension of $\mathbf{PA}(\mathbf{K4})$, the modal disjunction property is equivalent to the $\Sigma(\mathrm{B})$-soundness.