arXiv Science⌕ Search
Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 2105.10895

Data Quality in Empirical Software Engineering: A Targeted Review

Michael Franklin Bosu·Stephen G. MacDonell
View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Context: The utility of prediction models in empirical software engineering (ESE) is heavily reliant on the quality of the data used in building those models. Several data quality challenges such as noise, incompleteness, outliers and duplicate data points may be relevant in this regard. Objective: We investigate the reporting of three potentially influential elements of data quality in ESE studies: data collection, data pre-processing, and the identification of data quality issues. This enables us to establish how researchers view the topic of data quality and the mechanisms that are being used to address it. Greater awareness of data quality should inform both the sound conduct of ESE research and the robust practice of ESE data collection and processing. Method: We performed a targeted literature review of empirical software engineering studies covering the period January 2007 to September 2012. A total of 221 relevant studies met our inclusion criteria and were characterized in terms of their consideration and treatment of data quality. Results: We obtained useful insights as to how the ESE community considers these three elements of data quality. Only 23 of these 221 studies reported on all three elements of data quality considered in this paper. Conclusion: The reporting of data collection procedures is not documented consistently in ESE studies. It will be useful if data collection challenges are reported in order to improve our understanding of why there are problems with software engineering data sets and the models developed from them. More generally, data quality should be given far greater attention by the community. The improvement of data sets through enhanced data collection, pre-processing and quality assessment should lead to more reliable prediction models, thus improving the practice of software engineering.

Explore related subjects

cs.SE

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Michael Franklin Bosu, Stephen G. MacDonell. 2021-05-23. Data Quality in Empirical Software Engineering: A Targeted Review. https://doi.org/10.1145/2460999.2461024

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

CodePori: Large-Scale System for Autonomous Software Development Using Multi-Agent Technology

Existing Large Language Model (LLM)-based multi-agent systems are capable of executing tasks and providing data-driven recommendations, thereby enabling automation and decision support that assist practitioners in software development. However, existing studies have evaluated agents' performance on benchmark datasets, offering only binary pass-or-fail results, which provide limited insight into their practical applicability. There remains a lack of empirical research examining the potential and limitations of LLM-based agents in addressing challenging, real-world tasks, such as automated code generation for software systems. To this end, this study conducted a survey to empirically investigate the potential of LLM-based agents in software development, with participants evaluating the agents' performance in autonomous software development tasks. We employed a two-phase approach comprising (i) the development of a multi-agent system, CodePori, to automate code generation, and (ii) a survey-based evaluation to assess agent performance and explore its practical applicability to software development. Our results highlight that, while LLM-based multi-agent systems show potential for autonomous code generation, their successful integration requires addressing specific challenges (e.g., short-term memory limitations, hallucinations, and code smells) and incorporating a practitioner-centric perspective. The study also highlights the need to move beyond standard benchmarks for evaluating real-world applicability and identifies new opportunities for broader adoption in both industry and academia.

cs.SE↗
arXiv2026

SCLA: Automated Smart Contract Summarization via LLMs and Control Flow Prompt

Smart contract code summarization is crucial for efficient maintenance and vulnerability mitigation. While many studies use Large Language Models (LLMs) for summarization, their performance still falls short compared to fine-tuned models like CodeT5+ and CodeBERT. Some approaches combine LLMs with data flow analysis but fail to fully capture the hierarchy and control structures of the code, leading to information loss and degraded summarization quality. We propose SCLA, an LLM-based method that enhances summarization by integrating a Control Flow Graph (CFG) and semantic facts from the code's control flow into a semantically enriched prompt. SCLA uses a control flow extraction algorithm to derive control flows from semantic nodes in the Abstract Syntax Tree (AST) and constructs the corresponding CFG. Code semantic facts refer to both explicit and implicit information within the AST that is relevant to smart contracts. This method enables LLMs to better capture the structural and contextual dependencies of the code. We validate the effectiveness of SCLA through comprehensive experiments on a dataset of 40,000 real-world smart contracts. The experiment shows that SCLA significantly improves summarization quality, outperforming the SOTA baselines with improvements of 26.7%, 23.2%, 16.7%, and 14.7% in BLEU-4, METEOR, ROUGE-L, and BLEURT scores, respectively.

cs.SE↗
arXiv2026

Generalizing GUI Tests into Voice Assistant Capabilities through Behavioral Variation Discovery

Voice Assistants (VAs) and agentic assistants increasingly support app-specific tasks through natural-language interaction. However, these capabilities still require app-specific execution logic. Existing approaches either derive this logic dynamically from GUI context, require developers to define app functions, or reuse GUI tests that remain tied to a single concrete task instance. To address this limitation, we propose Test2VA, an approach that generalizes existing GUI tests into reusable app-specific VA capabilities. Test2VA adopts mutation as an exploration mechanism to discover plausible behavioral variations of test interactions, dynamically validates these variations on the running application with adapted assertions, and generalizes the validated task instances into capabilities that preserve the common task pattern while supporting broader user requests. We evaluate Test2VA on 100 Espresso GUI tests from ten real-world Android applications, covering 407 GUI events and 115 assertions. Across 396 reproduced events, Test2VA reduces 18,999 available mutation candidates to 1,272 predicted candidates before dynamic validation, identifies mutable events with 83.33% precision, 87.79% recall, and an 85.50% F1 score, and generates 65 VA capabilities. Among them, 64 execute successfully and 56 satisfy our capability quality requirements. We further analyze unsuccessful and low-quality cases to identify common causes of failure. Finally, we conduct a user study with 18 participants and 150 task observations to evaluate the generated capabilities in real app tasks. The VA successfully completes 123 observations, achieving an overall success rate of 82.0%, and 16 of 18 participants rate the VA as useful or very useful. These results show the feasibility of generalizing test-derived task logic into reusable app-specific VA capabilities.

cs.SE↗