$U(1)\otimes BRST$ symmetry, of on-shell T-matrix elements and (1-$ϕ$-I) Green's functions, determines the vacuum state of the Abelian Higgs Model from symmetry alone: minimization of the scalar-sector effective potential is unnecessary

Abstract

The weak-scale $U(1)_{Y}$ Abelian Higgs Model (AHM) is the spontaneous-symmetry-breaking gauge theory of a complex scalar $ϕ= \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(H + i π)$ and a vector $A_μ$. Global $U(1)_{Y}\otimes BRST$ symmetry emerges: when it is realized that on-shell T-matrix elements enjoy an extra $U(1)_{Y}$ global symmetry beyond the Lagragian's BRST symmetry. The symmetries co-exist: $U(1)_{Y}$ generators $δ_{U(1)_Y}$ commute with BRST generators s and $[δ_{U(1)_Y},s]{\cal L} = 0$. Two towers of Ward Takahashi identities (WTI), which include all-loop-orders quantum corrections, emerge: a tower of relations among off-shell 1-$ϕ$-I (but 1-$A_μ$-Reducible) Green's functions; another tower of Adler-zero WTI for on-shell T-matrix elements. The T-matrix's LSS theorem forces tadpoles to automatically vanish (equivalently $m^{2}_π = 0$) by symmetry alone. We show that, when the full symmetries of Lorenz gauge AHM are enforced on the scalar-sector effective potential, the vacuum state of the theory is specified/decided by symmetry alone. We use recursive WTI relations among Green's functions to include opeators of dimension $\geq 1$. We express the fully renormalized scalar-sector effective potential in a form which shows explicitly that, for small scalar field values, the gauge-independent vacuum state of the theory $\langle H\rangle_{renormalized} = Z^{1/2}_ϕ\langle H\rangle_{bare}$ is determined by $U(1)_{Y}\otimes BRST$ symmetry alone, without minimizing the effective potential.