Equilibrium Dynamics of the Sub-Ohmic Spin-boson Model Under Bias

Abstract

Using the bosonic numerical renormalization group method, we studied the equilibrium dynamical correlation function $C(ω)$ of the spin operator $σ_z$ for the biased sub-Ohmic spin-boson model. The small-$ω$ behavior $C(ω) \propto ω^s$ is found to be universal and independent of the bias $ε$ and the coupling strength $α$ (except at the quantum critical point $α=α_c$ and $ε=0$). Our NRG data also show $C(ω) \propto χ^{2}ω^{s}$ for a wide range of parameters, including the biased strong coupling regime ($ε\neq 0$ and $α> α_c$), supporting the general validity of the Shiba relation. Close to the quantum critical point $α_c$, the dependence of $C(ω)$ on $α$ and $ε$ is understood in terms of the competition between $ε$ and the crossover energy scale $ω_{0}^{\ast}$ of the unbiased case. $C(ω)$ is stable with respect to $ε$ for $ε\ll ε^{\ast}$. For $ε\gg ε^{\ast}$, it is suppressed by $ε$ in the low frequency regime. We establish that $ε^{\ast} \propto (ω_0^{\ast})^{1/θ}$ holds for all sub-Ohmic regime $0 \leqslant s < 1$, with $θ=2/(3s)$ for $0 < s \leqslant 1/2$ and $θ= 2/(1+s)$ for $1/2 < s < 1$. The variation of $C(ω)$ with $α$ and $ε$ is summarized into a crossover phase diagram on the $α-ε$ plane.